Miranda Kaufmann
Find me on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook and YouTube...
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Blog
  • Talks
  • History
  • Reviews
    • Book Reviews
    • Art and Theatre Reviews
  • Features
  • Food & Travel
  • Rugby
  • Contact

Thoughts on Belle

26/6/2014

7 Comments

 
Picture
So I finally saw Belle! I'm delighted that the film has been made and hope it is the first of many such stories of Africans in Britain to get the Hollywood treatment. Watching it has prompted many thoughts, but I'll try to distill the best of them here.

"Based on a True Story"?
Like any historical film "Based on a True Story", Belle takes liberties with the historical record. Alex von Tunzelman has made a good start on sifting the fact from fiction in her Reel History column in the Guardian. You can find a brief biography of Dido in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. Or read Paula Byrne's book for more background to the few details we have of Dido's life. You can read more about the legal history of slavery in England here. It's also worth paying a visit to Kenwood, especially if you take a look in the writing desk in the library, where you will find a brief pamphlet on " Lord Mansfield, Slavery and the Law", as well as reproductions of some of the original documents relating to Dido, including a letter she wrote on her great-uncle's behalf. 

Dido's status
The film shows Dido as occupying a strange position in the hierarchy of the Kenwood household. She is part of the family, and yet may not dine with them. The historical source for this is an entry in the diary of one Thomas Hutchinson, the exiled Governor of Massachusetts, who visited Lord Mansfield one evening in August 1779. In fact, this entry provides us with much of the known details of Dido's life. Hutchinson was hardly an unbiased observer, and mostly refers to Dido as "a Black". Paula Byrne points out that perhaps Dido did not attend dinner that night in order to shelter her from this man, rather than the other way round. Either way, the fact that she did not attend dinner on 29th August 1779 does not necessarily mean that she never dined with the family.

The fact that Dido helped manage the dairy is not an indicator of lower status. It was considered a genteel occupation for a lady, and even the Duke of Wellington took an interest in it, sharing his recipe for butter with Louisa, Lady Mansfield.
However, Dido was not the wealthy heiress that the film portrays. Her father left his money to two of his other illegitimate children. However, by giving her financial independence, the film asks interesting questions of the interplay of class, race, and cash in determining status in 18th century society. Although Dido was not an heiress, it was not inconceivable for a woman of her colour to be so. Many men who fathered children with enslaved women made attempts to provide for them, as Daniel Livesay's research has shown. Perhaps the best-known example of this was Nathaniel Wells, the son of William Wells and his house-slave, Juggy, who was educated in England, inherited his father's St. Kitts estate in 1794, and bought Piercefield estate near Chepstow, Monmouthshire in 1802, going on to become a Justice of the Peace in 1806 and Sheriff of Monmouthshire in 1818. 

Portraits of Africans 
One of the fascinating threads of the film for me was the interaction between Belle, and the images of Africans she saw around her, both growing up at Kenwood, and around her in the streets of London. The film shows her as fearful of having her own portrait painted, lest she be portrayed in the subservient pose she assumes is the only way for people of her complexion to appear in art. While we have no idea what she felt about portraiture, the film dramatises a deeper truth. There are large numbers of the sort of pictures Belle despised hanging on the walls of country houses across Britain, including this one of Henrietta of Lorraine and her page  by Van Dyck, now at Kenwood, and this portrait of Anne of Denmark and her groom, which I blogged about last year. However, there are also some fascinating portraits, besides Dido's, that give their black subjects dignity and character, such as Thomas Gainsborough's  1768 portrait of Ignatius Sancho. They key point about the portrait of Dido and her cousin, perhaps, is that it shows a black woman alongside a white woman in a position of relative equality. 

Picture
Dido and her cousin, by Zoffany, now at Scone Palace, Scotland.
The Legal Drama
I was pleased with the way the film brought to life the drama of the Zong case of 1783, but was amazed that it failed to make any mention of Lord Mansfield's earlier judgments regarding slavery, most pertinently, that in the Somerset case of 1772. I suppose the film-makers thought the audience could only deal with one monumental court case at a time! The script however, lifted the words Mansfield uttered in the Somerset case, on how slavery was odious, and placed them into his final judgment on the Zong.  

African Extras
I was intrigued to see a large number of African men shown in the film as attending the final judgement in the Zong case. According to the IMDB, one of these is meant to be Olaudah Equiano, played by Lamin Tamba. Equiano actually played a pivotal role in the Zong drama, as it was he who alerted abolitionist Granville Sharp to the case's existence.  Unfortunately, Dido does not speak to him, or the other well-dressed Africans she passes in the gallery, and so their stories remain untold. Her interaction with Mabel, the African maid is a little more detailed- and gives her the chance to ask Mansfield over breakfast: "Is Mabel a slave?" -This would have been an ideal opportunity for the Lord Chief Justice to explain the legal status of Africans in Britain, and his judgement in the Somerset case. Unfortunately, although we learn that Mabel is free, and paid wages, the subject is soon dismissed as not suitable for the breakfast table. 

Other Stories to Tell...
As I told the Observer newspaper in January, I really hope that in the wake of 12 Years A Slave, and Belle, " film directors will turn their attention to telling Britain's slavery stories such as Equiano's which would help a new generation understand their nation's role in a trade referred to as 'the great circuit' and remind them that "Africans have been living in Britain for centuries before the Windrush". There are so many great stories still to tell. Maybe I should write a list of suggestions for up and coming filmmakers who want Oscar-winning material? But that's a blog for another day...
7 Comments
Corinne Fowler
26/6/2014 12:53:58 am

I agree with your assessment, Miranda, and I think the film is a good thing all round. The timing of it is perfect, and it's a golden opportunity to open up this aspect of British history to new audiences. As you say, films need not be "true", as this is not a documentary. Nonetheless, it's important to get the right historical atmosphere, which this film generally seems to do, conveying the important message that there was a substantial and significant black presence during this period. And getting people to rethink the established symbolism of British country houses more broadly. I agree that the opportunity was perhaps lost to ensure that Dido is not seen as an historical anomaly but as one of thousands of untold stories. But good stuff. One thing I'd like to see more of in Byrne's book is praise for the local black history groups in bringing this to our collective attention in the first place.

Reply
Kathryn De Jesus
26/6/2014 05:23:13 pm

Really interesting piece, M. I really want to see this - may treat myself to the cinema this afternoon. Will bear in mind all your points!

Reply
Kathleen Chater
27/6/2014 07:32:47 pm

I loved it too, though I was irritated by the liberties taken with the facts. But I did appreciate the accuracy of the depiction of Dido's social position. About this time, some visitor who met the illegitimate daughter of the Duchess of Devonshire initially thought she was a governess. Dido was in exactly that place - not high enough to dine with important company, not low enough to be with the servants. Her birth was probably slightly more important than her colour.

It would have been far better to have used the Somerset case rather than the Zong, but that would have unbalanced the story, taking the focus away from Dido. But, like you say, at least the scriptwriter did read the Mansfield Judgement and used the line about slavery being odious from it.

Like you say, there are thousands of other stories to be told. Let's hope this is the start of more films which show Black people as people, not just victims where slavery defines them.

Reply
Shane Thomas
11/9/2014 10:00:58 am

Having seen the film, it's good to have clarity on which pieces of the movie were accurate, and which wasn't.

I think it was instructive to hear Amma Asante say that she wanted to make an Austen-esque story, with a woman of colour at the centre. I think that's what ultimately led the story, but it obviously lent well to a story in slavery-era Britain as the backdrop.

Reply
Lilian Nevins link
17/11/2014 04:28:46 pm

Very interesting piece, Your truly a breath of fresh air! As you say and I totally agree with we all not just the next generation need to know and understand that black people were here well before windrush and the role we played in British history. Thank you. X I will take my time to read a lot more of your works as now I have read Waaaay toooooo much and am LATE for work! Sssssssh

Reply
Madeleine Champagnie
18/4/2022 07:34:54 am

I hope you do write that list, Dr Kaufmann: post it on Twitter and tag Netflix, Amazon, Apple & all the rest!!

Reply
Columbus Solar Panels link
18/8/2022 12:32:05 am

Thanks for sharing tthis

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Dr. Miranda Kaufmann is a historian of Black British History living in North Wales. You can read a fuller bio here, and contact her here.

    Related Blogs/Sites

    Michael Ohajuru's Black Africans in Renaissance Europe blog

    Temi Odumosu's The Image of Black website

    The UCL Legacies of British Slave-ownership project Database and blog

    The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade Database

    The Black Presence in Britain

    Jeffrey Green's website, on Africans in 19th and early 20th Century Britain
     
    Untold Theatre 

    Categories

    All
    Africans In British Art
    Africans In Early Modern London
    Africans In Eighteenth Century England
    Africans In Renaissance Scotland
    Africans In Stuart England
    Africans In Tudor England
    Archives
    Black History
    Black History Month
    Early Modern England
    Exhibitions
    Heritage
    History
    Inclusive Curriculum
    Journalism
    Legal History
    Medical History
    National Curriculum
    Podcasts
    Politics
    Public History
    Radio History
    Research
    School History
    Shakespeare
    Slavery & Abolition
    Talks
    Travel
    Tv History

    Archives

    October 2022
    August 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    July 2021
    April 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    October 2019
    July 2019
    April 2019
    February 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    July 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    October 2015
    July 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    March 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.